I just watched
Black. It is very interesting! I think I haven't been so impressed with a plot since
Nine.
So many people die, and there are at least three different parties who are responsible for the deaths.
However, the ending disappointed me because I feel that there is something there that really makes no sense... (more on that later)
The main character being a Grim Reaper, there are of course supernatural stuff in the plot. But even though some of those strange stuff are handled well, some are not...
*** Spoilers ahead ***
For example, the Grim Reapers can teleport by going through a door (every door is a pintu suka hati!). So when this Grim Reaper goes into a human body, that human body can do the same. Then after some time, he finds that his teleportation sometimes works and sometimes doesn't... so he still has to drive a car sometimes! That, I can accept...because they admitted that it sometimes doesn't work! (Side anecdote: At one time, this Grim Reaper's police team needs to go somewhere urgently. Grim Reaper says to them that he will go by himself because it would be faster. His team leader asks him, "What, are you going to teleport there? What else would be faster than taking a police car with a siren?" It is funny seeing the Grim Reaper's face here, because teleporting was exactly what he was planning to do! :D )
But then there is a part where they say that the Grim Reaper's numbers are the date of their death. For example, 416 died on 16th April. But the main character is 444... so what does that correspond to? And also, what happens with people who die on the same date? (they didn't explain) So this part annoys me...they shouldn't have come up with a significance for the numbers if they couldn't handle all the numbers well!
At another point, they revealed that there was another character who was actually a Grim Reaper in a human's body, before he died. This Grim Reaper somehow managed to continue the life of the human being without drawing suspicion to himself. But when our hero is taken over by the Grim Reaper, he doesn't know how to do some human things, and only relies on the bullet in his brain to explain his memory loss and his inability to do some basic things.
The way they make the Grim Reaper know how to do some things, but not know how to do others, is really inconsistent. The premise is that he has been observing humans, but not doing what they do, like driving cars (the first time he drives, he mutters that "it looked easier when watching them". He doesn't know he needs to wear pants, but for some other things, he seems to do just fine... (there are loads of examples, but let's stop here :P )
They say that if a Grim Reaper kills a human, he would be dissipated (the soul disappears, it seems, and cannot go to either paradise or hell, and cannot be reborn). At first they said that this was the maximum penalty for a Grim Reaper, and then our hero suddenly discovers that it wasn't, and that the maximum penalty was actually that you would cease to exist, and that no one would remember you.
So now here's the major SPOILER (don't blame me if you continue reading; you have been warned): The hero that was the Grim Reaper was actually the first love of the heroine (haih, why do they like this kind of first-love storylines so much), who had died and become a Grim Reaper. So now, in a human body, he had fallen in love with the heroine (and she with him), and he felt that she would be sad to lose him and find out how her first love had died. So after killing all the bad guys to keep her safe, he decides to go and accept his punishment. Instead of dissipation, he requests for the maximum penalty, so that the heroine would forget him and go on living her life happily.
I would have been okay with this ending, except that at the very end, they show the heroine having lived to a very old age, and when she dies (of old age, of course), our hero's soul was there as the Grim Reaper to take her away. At that point, she remembers him, and it's like they manage to get together after all! WHAT?!! This is your maximum penalty? You are erased from the memory of living people, but souls remember you, and you get to continue being a happy soul? Doesn't that "ceasing to exist" part get added on top of your dissipation? I just cannot accept this ridiculous ending...
And what's more, this ending means that some people's deaths might not have happened, and that means rewriting time! What do the Grim Reapers do, bring back the souls of people who have died, and tell them they didn't die after all? *eye roll*
Anyway, the whole drama was still very enjoyable (with the exception of the second episode, where I feel they dragged on the funny antics for too long), and the plot was awesome, so I still like it. But the ending made my opinion of it drop A LOT!
I actually think that this plot would have made a great drama without the Grim Reaper arc. It's a pity that they felt they needed that for a unique selling point.